Why interchangeable brands struggle to retain customers

On this page

The jar is empty. Your customer is standing in the kitchen, picks up their phone, and types something in. What they type decides whether you get that second order. And in most cases they don’t type your name.

We looked it up for one category: magnesium, one of the best-selling supplements in the Netherlands. These are the monthly search volumes.

What people actually search for

Search term Searches per month
magnesium 49,500
magnesium tablets 4,400
buy magnesium 720
Together, without a brand name 54,620
vitakruid magnesium 5,400
lucovitaal magnesium 4,400
orthica magnesium 1,000
bonusan magnesium 720
flinndal magnesium 590
vitals magnesium 480
artelle magnesium 10
Together, with a brand name 12,600

For every search that mentions a brand, there are more than four that don’t. But the real story is in the split within those 12,600.

Two brands take 9,800 of them. The five other brands together, including names that advertise heavily and run a subscription model, come to 2,800. Against 54,620 searches in which nobody names a brand.

One in twenty. That is the challengers’ share of the attention in their own category.

This is not a search problem

The temptation is to read this as a findability question. More content, better positions, higher bids on the category term.

But look again at what is happening. Someone who bought magnesium from you, emptied the jar, and needs magnesium again three months later, types “magnesium”. Not your name. That customer had a good experience, is not dissatisfied, and still ends up on a results page where ten brands sit side by side.

Then you compete all over again. For a customer you have already paid for.

The search bar here is not a channel but a measuring instrument. It shows how many people remembered your name, and the answer is usually: far fewer than you think.

Why discounting makes it worse

The standard response to customers who stay away is a discount code. Ten per cent off your next order, twenty if you take a subscription.

That works, in the sense that orders come out of it. But you are buying a customer who comes back on price, and that customer is by definition the customer of your next competitor with a better offer. You have bought the second order and given away the third.

Worse: you have taught yourself that it works. This month’s figures look better, so you do it again next month, and that is how you build a customer base that only exists as long as the discount does.

What being remembered actually means

Being remembered sounds soft and is barely measurable, but in a consumable category it breaks down into three very concrete things.

A name. Does the customer know what you are called, or do they only know what they bought? If the answer is “a jar of magnesium”, you have become a product category.

A reason. Is there something about which they would say: that is why I buy it from them. Not a property everyone claims, but something they can make a sentence out of to their partner.

A moment. Are you somewhere they go at the moment the jar is empty, or do they have to find you again on their own?

Most brands work only on the third. That is also the easiest: a flow, a reminder, a subscription. But the third doesn’t work without the first two. A reminder email from a brand whose name the customer doesn’t recognise is an advertisement.

You cannot store a commodity

That is the core. Retention is not an email matter but a memory matter, and memory is a brand matter.

If ten brands promise the same thing in the same words, the cheapest is always good enough. Then there is no reason to come back except habit and price, and both are for sale by your competitor. Whoever promises the same as the rest is remembered as the rest, so as nobody.

We laid the product pages from this category side by side to see what they actually say. The answer is more predictable than you would hope.

What you do with this

Look up the monthly search volume for your category term and for your own brand name plus that term. The ratio is your brand memory, and it takes ten minutes to know it.

Then look in your own data at how many of your repeat orders come in through direct traffic or through your brand name, and how many through an ad or a category search. That second part is the group you have paid for twice.

And ask yourself the question above: can one of your customers explain in a single sentence why they buy from you and not from the brand next to you. If you cannot write the answer down, they cannot think of it.